The Differences Between Cedar Shingles And Shakes

The Differences Between Cedar Shingles And Shakes

When it comes to choosing the right roofing material, cedar shingles and shakes are both popular options. However, they have distinct differences in their appearance, manufacturing process, and durability.

Cedar shingles are thinner and sawn smooth on both sides. They are commonly used for roofing and sidewalls in residential and commercial buildings. Cedar shingles come in different grades, with Grade 1 being the highest quality and Grade 3 being more affordable for sheds or walls. On the other hand, cedar shakes have a rough and natural appearance as they are hand split. There are three types of shakes available, including heavy split & resawn, medium split and resawn, and tapersawn shake. Shakes also have different grain cuts, including flat grain, slash grain, and edge grain. Shakes are known for their rustic appeal and can be used for roofing or siding.

When deciding between cedar shingles and shakes, the choice ultimately depends on the desired aesthetic and application. Now, let’s take a closer look at the key differences between these two options.

Key Takeaways:

  • Cedar shingles are thinner and sawn smooth on both sides.
  • Cedar shakes have a rough and natural appearance as they are hand split.
  • There are different types of shakes, including heavy split & resawn, medium split and resawn, and tapersawn shake.
  • Shakes have different grain cuts, including flat grain, slash grain, and edge grain.
  • Choosing between cedar shingles and shakes depends on the desired aesthetic and application.

Durability and Maintenance of Cedar Shingles And Shakes

When considering the durability of cedar shingles and shakes, it’s important to note the unique qualities of each. Cedar shakes, with their thicker composition and premium grade wood, are generally considered more durable than shingles. The extra thickness allows shakes to withstand extreme weather conditions better and contribute to their longer lifespan. However, it’s worth mentioning that shakes may not lay completely flat on the roof, requiring the installation of felt paper between courses to provide protection against wind-blown precipitation.

Cedar shingles, on the other hand, can also offer a highly weatherproof system when properly installed. With three overlapping layers, they can provide excellent resistance to water penetration and create a robust roofing solution. While they may not be as thick as shakes, cedar shingles still offer a level of durability that can withstand the test of time.

When it comes to maintenance, both cedar shingles and shakes require some level of care to ensure their longevity. Regular inspections will help identify any damaged or missing pieces that need replacing. Additionally, it’s important to keep the roof surface clean from debris, such as leaves or branches, to prevent moisture retention and the growth of algae or moss. Periodic treatments with wood preservatives or stains can enhance the natural color and protect against weathering.

Cedar ShinglesCedar Shakes
DurabilityHigh (with proper installation)Very High
MaintenanceRegular inspections, cleaning, and treatmentsRegular inspections, cleaning, and treatments
Lifespan15-30 years30-50 years
AppearanceSmooth and uniformRustic and textured

Cost and Environmental Benefits of Cedar Shingles And Shakes

When comparing the cost of cedar shingles and shakes, it’s important to consider several factors. Generally, shakes tend to be more expensive than shingles due to their thicker nature and rustic appearance. However, it’s crucial to remember that the long-term value and durability of cedar roofing materials should be taken into account when comparing costs. While shakes may have a higher upfront cost, their longer lifespan and ability to withstand extreme weather conditions can make them a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Environmental Benefits

In addition to their aesthetic appeal and durability, cedar shingles and shakes offer several environmental benefits. Cedar is a sustainable and renewable resource, making it an environmentally friendly choice for roofing materials. Cedar trees are harvested from responsibly managed forests, ensuring the long-term health and sustainability of these natural resources. Furthermore, cedar roofing materials are biodegradable and have a lower carbon footprint compared to synthetic alternatives, making them an eco-conscious choice for homeowners.

Cost Comparison

Let’s take a closer look at how the costs of cedar shingles and shakes compare. While shakes may initially have a higher price tag, the longevity of these premium grade wood roofing materials can offset their higher upfront cost. Additionally, cedar shingles offer a more affordable option, particularly for Grade 3 shingles, which are suitable for sheds or walls. It’s important to weigh the initial cost against the lifespan and durability of the chosen roofing material to make an informed decision that aligns with both budget and long-term goals.

In conclusion, the cost comparison between cedar shingles and shakes is influenced by various factors such as grade, thickness, and installation requirements. While shakes may be more expensive initially, their durability and rustic charm can make them a worthwhile investment. On the other hand, cedar shingles provide a cost-effective option for those seeking a more affordable alternative. Regardless of the choice, both options offer environmental benefits, making cedar roofing materials a sustainable and responsible choice for homeowners.

FAQ

What is the difference between cedar shingles and shakes?

Cedar shingles are thinner, sawn smooth on both sides, and commonly used for both roofing and sidewalls. Cedar shakes have a rough, natural appearance as they are hand split.

What are the different grades of cedar shingles?

Cedar shingles come in different grades, with Grade 1 being the highest quality and Grade 3 being more affordable for sheds or walls.

What are the different types and grain cuts of cedar shakes?

Cedar shakes have three types, including heavy split & resawn, medium split and resawn, and tapersawn shake. They also have different grain cuts, including flat grain, slash grain, and edge grain.

Can cedar shingles and shakes be used for both roofing and siding?

Yes, both cedar shingles and shakes can be used for both roofing and siding depending on the desired aesthetic and application.

Which is more durable, cedar shingles or shakes?

Cedar shakes are generally considered more durable than shingles due to their thickness and premium grade wood.

Do cedar shingles and shakes require any special maintenance?

Both cedar shingles and shakes require regular maintenance, including periodic cleaning and treating with preservatives to prevent decay.

Are cedar shingles and shakes environmentally friendly?

Yes, cedar shingles and shakes are considered environmentally friendly as they are a renewable resource and can be recycled or composted at the end of their lifespan.

Are cedar shingles and shakes costly compared to other roofing materials?

The cost of cedar shingles and shakes can vary depending on the grade, thickness, and installation requirements. Generally, shakes tend to be more expensive due to their thicker nature and rustic appearance.

Related Posts

error: Content is protected !!
0

Compare