What is a Disadvantage of Joint Tenancy Ownership?

Joint tenancy is a popular form of property ownership, particularly among couples and business partners. It allows two or more people to hold equal shares in assets such as a home, a bank account, or an investment portfolio.

While joint tenancy offers several benefits, including the right of survivorship and the avoidance of probate, it also has its downsides.

This article will explore the disadvantages of joint tenancy ownership, focusing on the lack of control over property disposition, impact on estate planning, tax implications, and potential for disputes among co-owners.

Lack of Control Over Property Disposition

One of the main disadvantages of joint tenancy is the lack of control over the disposition of the property. In a joint tenancy, the surviving owner automatically inherits the deceased owner’s share of the property, regardless of the deceased owner’s wishes.

This can thwart the deceased owner’s desire to bequeath their interest in the property to someone other than the surviving co-owner.

For instance, if a decedent held property in joint tenancy with a sibling and later got married intending for the property to go to the spouse, the sibling may gain full ownership of the property upon the decedent’s death, even if the decedent had willed that property to their surviving spouse.

Moreover, joint tenants cannot dispose of their share of the property to anyone without obtaining consent from the other joint tenants.

This can limit the flexibility of the joint tenants in managing their property interests.

Impact on Estate Planning

Joint tenancy can also have significant implications for estate planning. If a co-owner intends to bequeath their interest in a property to someone other than the surviving co-owner, the joint tenancy form of ownership will thwart that desire.

Furthermore, joint tenancy can lead to unintended consequences in the distribution of the property. For example, if one joint tenant transfers their interest in the property to a third party, it results in a tenancy in common after the transfer.

This could potentially lead to the property being distributed to unintended beneficiaries or heirs.

Tax Implications

Joint tenancy can also have tax implications. While joint tenancy avoids probate, it does not avoid estate taxes.

The IRS treats the first owner to die as the only owner of assets held in joint tenancy, which can lead to unnecessary taxes and liability for the other co-owner’s debts.

Moreover, when there is a change in ownership of an interest in real property, there is a tax reassessment as to that interest being transferred.

This usually occurs when an interest in the property is being transferred to a third party. If no original transferors are left, then it is considered a change in ownership, and there will be a tax reassessment

Additionally, joint tenancy can create future tax liabilities if one of the spouses dies and the property is sold.

In joint tenancy, there is only a 50% or half stepped up in cost basis, which can lead to higher tax liabilities.

Potential for Disputes Among Co-Owners

Joint tenancy can also lead to disputes among co-owners. Since each joint tenant owns an undivided interest in the property, any small dispute could jeopardize the entire estate.

For example, if one joint tenant wishes to sell the property but the other does not, this could lead to a dispute. Similarly, if one joint tenant fails to contribute to the costs of maintaining the property, this could also lead to disagreements

These are other disadvantages or drawbacks of owning property in joint tenancy include:

Asset protection issues – Creditors of any one owner can potentially force a sale of the entire property to collect on debts. The property is vulnerable to the financial issues of any co-tenant.
Binding relationship – Joint tenants are tied together legally in the property ownership, even if personal relationships change. This can make dissolving co-ownership complex.
No customized inheritance – The survivorship right controls what happens to the ownership interest when someone dies. It cannot be customized like a will.
Loss of step-up tax basis – When the first owner dies, there is no step up in tax basis on the entire property value for the survivor.
Difficulty severing interests – Unilateral severance of a joint tenancy may not be possible in some cases without the consent of all co-owners.

In conclusion, while joint tenancy offers several benefits, it also has significant disadvantages. These include a lack of control over property disposition, potential impacts on estate planning, tax implications, and the potential for disputes among co-owners.

Therefore, it’s important to carefully consider these factors and consult with a legal professional before deciding to hold property as joint tenants.

Joint Tenancy Vs Tenancy In Common

The key differences are the right of survivorship and ability to control passing your interest when you die.

Joint tenancy causes ownership to go directly to survivors, while tenancy in common allows more control through a will. Overall, tenancy in common provides more flexibility for unequal interests and customized inheritance.

Here is a summary comparing joint tenancy and tenancy in common for property ownership:

Joint Tenancy

Ownership by two or more people together.
Owners have equal, undivided interests in the property.
Key right of survivorship – when one owner dies, their interest passes to the surviving owner(s) automatically.
Last survivor gets full ownership of property.
Passing by survivorship avoids probate.
Owners’ interests cannot be transferred through a will.
Unilateral severance may be possible to break the joint tenancy.

Tenancy in Common

Ownership by two or more people together.
Owners can hold unequal interests – does not have to be divided equally.
No right of survivorship. Deceased owner’s interest passes to heirs, not automatically to surviving owners.
Each interest may be freely transferred or willed to someone else.
If one owner dies, their heirs become tenants in common with the surviving owners.
No restrictions on severing interests unilaterally.

0 Shares

What is a Disadvantage of Joint Tenancy Ownership?