Wood Shake Roof vs. Cedar Shake Roof: How Do They Compare?

Wood Shake Roof vs. Cedar Shake Roof: How Do They Compare?

Wood Shake Roof vs. Cedar Shake Roof: How Do They Compare?

When considering roofing options for a new home or a renovation, wood shake roof and cedar shake roof frequently come up in discussions. Both options provide aesthetic appeal and durability but differ in various aspects. Understanding these differences is crucial for making an informed decision about roofing materials.

What is a Wood Shake Roof?

A wood shake roof is composed of individual pieces of wood that are split from logs, creating a rougher texture. This type of roofing is known for its rustic appearance and ability to blend seamlessly with natural surroundings.

Key Features:

• Materials: Often made from various types of wood, including cedar, redwood, and pine.
• Thickness: Typically thicker than wood shingles, offering enhanced durability.
• Installation: Requires expert craftsmanship, as each piece is manually placed.

Cedar Shake Roofing Material

A cedar shake roof specifically uses cedar wood, renowned for its natural resistance to rot, insects, and harsh weather conditions. This type of roofing is prized for its beauty and longevity.

Cedar Shake Key Features:

Cedar Shake Roof vs. Wood Shingle Roof

While both cedar shakes and wood shingles are made from wood, there are distinct differences between them.

Comparison Table:

Cedar Shake Roof Details

Cedar shake roofs come with a range of benefits that contribute to their popularity. Here’s a deeper look into these aspects:

• Aesthetic Appeal: The natural look of cedar enhances curb appeal.
• Energy Efficiency: Wood has natural insulating properties, helping regulate indoor temperatures.
• Environmental Impact: Cedar is a renewable resource, especially when sourced sustainably.
• Maintenance Needs: Requires regular maintenance to prolong lifespan, including cleaning and treating for mold.

Cedar Shake Roof Price

The cedar shake roof price can vary based on multiple factors, including region, installation complexity, and local material costs. On average, homeowners can expect to pay between $6 to $12 per square foot for cedar shake roofing.

Cost Comparison Table:

Cedar Shake Roof vs Asphalt Shingles

When comparing cedar shake roof vs asphalt shingles, it’s essential to consider various factors:

1. Durability: Cedar shakes can last longer than asphalt shingles, particularly in favorable climates.
2. Aesthetics: Cedar offers a more traditional and rustic look, while asphalt is available in a range of styles but lacks the same natural appeal.
3. Cost: Asphalt shingles are generally more affordable, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners.

Wood Shake vs. Wood Shingle Roof

The distinction between wood shake vs wood shingle roof lies mainly in their construction and appearance.

• Wood Shakes: Thicker, more rugged, and typically more durable.
• Wood Shingles: Smoother, thinner, and often more uniform in appearance.

Comparison Table:

Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof

The rise of synthetic cedar shake roofs provides an alternative that mimics the appearance of natural wood while offering additional benefits.

Advantages of Synthetic Cedar Shake:

• Durability: Resistant to warping, fading, and cracking.
• Cost-Effective: Often cheaper than real cedar.
• Maintenance: Requires less upkeep than natural wood.

Cedar Shake Roof Replacement

When it comes to cedar shake roof replacement, understanding the signs of wear is crucial. Common indicators include:

• Cracking or Splitting: Natural wood can develop cracks over time.
• Moss or Algae Growth: This can indicate moisture retention, which compromises integrity.
• Curling Edges: A sign of age and potential leaks.

How to Cedar Shake Roof

Installing a cedar shake roof requires a skilled approach. Here’s a basic overview of the process:

1. Preparation: Remove old roofing materials and inspect the decking.
2. Underlayment: Install a waterproof underlayment to protect against leaks.
3. Installation: Begin at the lowest point, ensuring overlapping pieces for water runoff.
4. Finishing Touches: Install ridge caps and inspect for any gaps.

Cedar Shake Look-Alike Roofing

For those desiring the cedar shake look-alike roofing but with less maintenance and cost, several synthetic options exist. These materials often replicate the texture and color of cedar shakes while providing enhanced durability.

Popular Synthetic Options:

• Fiber Cement: Offers durability and fire resistance.
• Vinyl: Lightweight and low maintenance.
• Composite: Blends wood fibers and plastic for a realistic appearance.

Cost Cedar Shake Roof vs Composite

When comparing the cost cedar shake roof vs composite, the latter typically comes out as a more economical option. Composite roofing can range from $3 to $8 per square foot, while cedar shakes can cost between $6 to $12 per square foot.

The Best Synthetic Cedar Shake Roof

If you’re considering a synthetic option, it’s crucial to select the best synthetic cedar shake roof. Look for products that:

• Mimic Texture: Closely resemble the natural grain of cedar.
• UV Resistance: Offer protection against sun damage.
• Warranty: A longer warranty often indicates higher quality.

Conclusion

In choosing between a wood shake roof and a cedar shake roof, various factors come into play, including aesthetics, durability, cost, and maintenance requirements. While cedar offers unparalleled beauty and longevity, wood shakes provide a more rustic charm. Synthetic options also present viable alternatives for those looking for reduced maintenance and enhanced durability. Ultimately, understanding these distinctions can help homeowners make the best choice for their specific needs and preferences.