Prior Appropriation Water Rights Definition & Examples

Prior Appropriation Water Rights Definition & Examples

Prior Appropriation Water Rights Definition & Examples

Prior Appropriation Water Rights Meaning

Prior appropriation water rights, often referred to as the prior appropriation doctrine, is a legal framework used to govern the allocation of water rights in the United States. This doctrine is based on the principle of “first in time, first in right,” meaning that the first person to use or divert a quantity of water from a water source for a beneficial use or purpose has the exclusive right to continue using that water for that specific purpose.

In other words, the individual or entity who initially puts water to a beneficial use gains a senior water right, which takes precedence over later appropriators.

This system has historical roots in the Western United States and emerged as a response to the scarcity of water resources. It allows for the diversion of water from its source to fulfill various purposes, such as agriculture, industry, or municipal use.

In a prior appropriation jurisdiction, water rights are granted based on the timing of use, the place of use, and the intended purpose of use. The system provides a structured way to manage water resources and prevent conflicts over water allocation.

Unlike riparian rights, which are based on land ownership and adjacency to water bodies, prior appropriation is founded on the “first in time, first in right” principle. Under this doctrine, the first individuals or entities to divert and use water for beneficial purposes have senior or superior rights, and these rights take precedence over later appropriators.

Key Components Of Prior Appropriation Water Rights

Here are the key components of prior appropriation water rights:

  1. “First in Time, First in Right”: As mentioned, the central tenet of prior appropriation is that those who first put water to beneficial use have priority. The first appropriators are granted senior water rights, and they are entitled to their full allocation of water before junior appropriators receive any.
  2. Beneficial Use: The water must be used for a beneficial purpose to qualify for appropriation. Beneficial uses vary by jurisdiction but typically include irrigation, municipal water supply, industrial processes, and more.
  3. No Relation to Riparian Ownership: Unlike riparian rights, prior appropriation is not tied to land ownership adjacent to water bodies. It doesn’t matter if the appropriator owns the land or has any riparian connection to the water source.
  4. Diversion and Conveyance: The doctrine often involves diverting water from its natural source, conveying it through ditches, canals, or pipelines, and applying it to the intended beneficial use.
  5. Use It or Lose It: In many prior appropriation systems, water rights are subject to a “use it or lose it” principle. If a water right holder fails to use their allocation for a specific period, the unused water may revert to the state or be allocated to other users.
  6. Priority System: Prior appropriation establishes a priority system, where senior water rights holders have the first call on available water. When water becomes scarce during droughts or shortages, junior rights holders may receive little to no allocation until senior rights holders have been satisfied.
  7. Registration and Administration: Many jurisdictions with prior appropriation systems require the registration and administration of water rights. This helps track water allocations, ensure compliance with beneficial use requirements, and manage water distribution.
  8. Water Rights Transfers: Water rights under prior appropriation can often be transferred or sold to other users or entities, subject to approval by relevant authorities.
  9. State Control: While riparian rights are often subject to local or regional control, prior appropriation is more centralized and frequently regulated at the state level. State agencies oversee water rights allocation and management.
  10. Conflicts and Adjudication: Disputes can arise when water shortages occur or when new users seek water rights. In such cases, adjudication processes, which may involve the courts, are used to resolve conflicts and clarify rights.

Historical Context:

Prior appropriation has its roots in the arid Western United States, where water scarcity and competition for water resources led to the development of this system. It has since been adopted in other regions facing water management challenges.

Application of Prior Appropriation Water Rights:

Prior appropriation systems are prevalent in the western U.S., with states like Colorado, California, and Nevada relying on this framework for water rights allocation. However, it is not the dominant system in all areas, and water rights systems can vary significantly between regions.

Prior Appropriation Water Rights Examples

Here are a couple of examples that illustrate the concept of prior appropriation water rights:

Agricultural Water Use in the Western United States:

Prior appropriation water rights play a significant role in the agricultural sector, particularly in the arid Western United States. Let’s consider a hypothetical example in Colorado, where this system is commonly applied.

Scenario: A farmer, John, owns a piece of land alongside a river. He is one of the earliest settlers in the area and is the first to divert water from the river to irrigate his crops. John’s priority date for his water rights is 1880, meaning he has senior water rights.

Application: In times of drought or water scarcity, water is allocated based on seniority. John’s senior water rights grant him the first call on the available water. He can continue to irrigate his fields, ensuring the survival of his crops even during dry spells.

Junior water rights holders, who started diverting water more recently, will only receive water once John’s allocation has been met.

Municipal Water Supply in California:

Prior appropriation is not limited to agriculture; it also extends to municipal water supply. Let’s explore an example in California, another state with prior appropriation water rights.

Scenario: The city of Aridville, California, relies on a nearby river for its municipal water supply. The city has a water treatment plant that diverts water from the river, treats it, and distributes it to residents and businesses. The city’s water rights date back to the early 1900s.

Application: In years of water shortage or when the river’s flow decreases, Aridville’s water supply is governed by the priority system. The city’s senior water rights ensure that it has the first claim to available water.

As long as the city’s allocation is satisfied, it can continue to provide water to its residents. Junior water rights holders, such as some industrial users further downstream, may face water restrictions or be unable to access water until the city’s needs are met.

Recreational Use in a River Basin:

Prior appropriation water rights can also apply to recreational activities. Let’s consider a river basin in Montana, where various individuals and organizations hold water rights for recreation.

Scenario: The river basin is a popular destination for fishing, boating, and other recreational activities. Multiple fishing lodges and outfitters are present, each with its own water rights. The lodges’ water rights are assigned priority dates based on when they began operations.

Application: During the peak summer season, the river experiences increased recreational demand. Water rights prioritization comes into play when allocating water for various purposes. Lodges with senior water rights can ensure they have the necessary flow for their guests’ activities. In contrast, newer operators may find their water access restricted during times of high demand.

These examples highlight how prior appropriation water rights are applied in different contexts, including agriculture, municipal supply, and recreational use.

The “first in time, first in right” principle governs water allocation, ensuring that senior water rights holders have precedence in accessing available water resources. This system is designed to address water scarcity and competition for limited water supplies while respecting historical usage and priorities.

More examples of prior appropriation water rights:

Here are a few  more examples of prior appropriation water rights:
  • Farmer A began diverting water from a river to irrigate his crops in 1850. Farmer B bought land downstream and started diverting water from the same river in 1880. Under the prior appropriation doctrine, Farmer A has senior water rights, meaning he can divert his full allotment of water before Farmer B can take any, especially in times of shortage.
  • Mining Company X began diverting water from a creek to operate its mine in 1860. Rancher Y bought land with creek access upstream of the mine in 1890 and started diverting water for his cattle. Mining Company X has senior water rights over Rancher Y.
  • Irrigation District 1 built the first diversion dams and canals on a river in 1870 to deliver water to area farms. Irrigation District 2 was formed in 1900 and also started diverting from the river. In times of drought, Irrigation District 1 would have priority access to the water.
  • The city of Alpha began taking water from a lake for municipal use in 1840. Farmer Z started irrigating his fields from the same lake in 1880. The city of Alpha has senior water rights, so can take its full allotment before Farmer Z can access water in times of shortage.
  • Hydroelectric Company A built the first dam on a river in 1902 to generate power. Horticultural Business B started diverting water from the same river in 1912 for crop irrigation. Hydroelectric Company A has senior water rights over Horticultural Business B.

In general, under prior appropriation, the oldest water rights have senior priority over more junior rights when there is not enough water to satisfy all users. This rewards early settlers and users who claimed water rights first.

Related Posts

error: Content is protected !!